
The IAB tried to fix AI attribution and wrote a to-do list instead
Only 8.8% of visits after an AI recommendation came straight from the AI, in data the IAB cites.
Happy Wednesday.
Your last-click report has a new kind of mistake in it, and it looks exactly like good news for search.
Someone asks ChatGPT for the best option in your category, reads your name, then Googles you two days later and buys. Your dashboard credits paid search or direct. The AI that did the persuading gets nothing, and next year's budget follows the credit.
The IAB spent four months trying to fix that. Last Thursday it published the AI-Era Attribution Blueprint, which sorts conversions into human-owned, AI-assisted and AI-executed, then asks who created the intent, who made the decision and who completed the purchase, MarTech reports. Every claim needs evidence.
The evidence is the problem. Caroline Giegerich, the IAB's vp of AI, told a roundtable the working group set out to assign credit and ended up with "more of a call to action to the industry." In her words, "There are evidence layers that are missing," per Digiday.
Similarweb data cited in the report shows the size of the hole. People who got a brand recommendation from an AI assistant were 2.5 times more likely to visit that brand's site within seven days. Only 8.8% of those visits came directly from AI referrals. Search got 55.9% and direct got 19.9%.
The recommendations are sensible. AI platforms should say whether a recommendation was paid or organic, disclose which sources informed it and label AI-originated traffic consistently. Brands should estimate how many conversions fall into each of the three pathways. None of it is binding, and the platforms still hold most of the data.
I'd use the vocabulary anyway, starting this quarter. It gives you a way to tell finance that some of your search growth started somewhere you can't see, without sounding like you're making excuses.
If more than half of AI-sparked visits show up as search in your reports, how much of your search budget is really an AI budget?
ALSO TODAY
Google is testing removing AI Mode from the search tab bar and the "Ask anything" box from AI Overviews, per Search Engine Roundtable.
Lyft is testing a "home masthead" ad that gives one brand the whole home screen riders see before booking, with Pluto TV and Google among the first, Adweek reports.
OpenAI launched ChatGPT Wallet, letting its agents pay with stand-in card numbers after users approve each purchase, for U.S. Pro subscribers first, PPC Land reports.
Today’s sponsor:
Are you in the top 3? Do you know who is?
The AI Visibility Leaderboard from daydream will tell you — for free. Built on 60,726 AI answers and over half a million citations in the last 3 months alone, it ranks 145 brands across 18 categories. See who's winning your category.
BONUS: Get a personalized AI visibility dashboard for your brand based on what real buyers ask AI. See how often AI recommends you versus your competitors, and AI's sources, ready to share with your team.
REQUEST MY FREE AI VISIBILITY DASHBOARD →
TALK ON THE MARKET
Rand Fishkin, CEO of SparkToro, on five years of web traffic:
Two caveats before you forward it. Rand reposted this after deleting a version with a wrong graph, and the 24% user growth spans a 2025 revision in how India and China report internet use, as SEJ points out. The 12% fall in visits doesn't depend on that. Fewer visits means fewer clicks to attribute, which is today's Focus in one chart.
NUMBERS MATTER
63%. How many fewer display impressions Amazon has told advertisers to expect across its homepage, product pages and search results from January 1, when it starts counting an impression once the ad renders on screen instead of when it starts downloading, Digiday reports. Google announced a similar change, effective February 17.
Same ads, smaller number. Buyers expect higher CPMs and say outcomes like ROAS shouldn't move. If your media mix model or automated reporting leans on impressions, recalibrate before January's numbers reach the board.
TRY THIS TODAY
Estimate how much of your search and direct revenue started in an AI answer.
Using the attached CRM opportunities, web analytics and "how did you hear about us" answers, compare what each source says about search and direct revenue over the last two quarters.
Then estimate the share that likely began in an AI assistant, show the math, and list the three pieces of evidence we'd need to prove it.Paste in: two quarters of CRM opportunities with source fields, your analytics channel report and any self-reported attribution answers. You get back: a reconciliation table, an estimate with its assumptions and an evidence wishlist. The full Content ROI Attribution prompt adds a recommended attribution model, five revenue KPIs and a 90-day baseline plan.
CMO CORNER
The more decisions you make, the more dependency you create.
Attribution is where CMOs end up making every call personally. Which number goes in the board deck, which channel gets the credit, which model we trust this quarter. Each decision feels like protecting the team. Each one also teaches them to wait for you.
The IAB blueprint is useful because it moves the argument from opinion to evidence. Who created the intent, who made the decision, who completed the sale, and what proof each claim needs. That's a rule your team can apply without you in the room.
So write your own version this week. One page: what counts as evidence for a paid, organic or AI-assisted claim, and who settles it when two channels claim the same deal. Give it to your ops lead and your channel owners.
Then, at the next budget review, stay quiet for the first half hour. If they settle the credit fight with the page, that's one decision you never have to make again.
TOOL UPGRADE
Three tools for tracing what actually produced the lead:
WhatConverts — best for service businesses where calls are the conversion, and for agencies proving channel ROI. Try WhatConverts here →
Viktor — best for teams that want an AI employee in Slack or Teams to pull numbers from Stripe, GA4 and HubSpot and post the recap on schedule. Try Viktor here →
Unbounce — best for teams running several landing page variants that want page building and conversion testing without developers. Try Unbounce here →
→ We have 300+ curated, filtered, and categorized AI tools in our directory. Browse to find the best ones that help your marketing team.
LEARN THIS
Finding ROI in AI Workflows is a 40-minute workshop replay built around the 3A Framework: Audit, Analyze, Act. It shows how to find operational debt and hidden coordination costs, run a lightweight AI readiness audit and launch a pilot that proves ROI fast. Use it when your team experiments with AI but can't show executives the value.
First step this week: audit one workflow end to end and write down every handoff and every wait. That list is your baseline before anyone pilots anything.
→ We publish workshops, courses, guides, manuals, and more on AI marketing for free. Browse our learning resources for free.
BRAND SLOP
Meta's AI ad tools took discounts from a store's website and showed them in its Facebook and Instagram ads, "even when the shop had turned promotions off on the ad it copied," as PPC Land reported, Marketing Dive notes.
Digital marketing advisor Bram Van der Hallen spotted it. When the option to show offers detected from your website and ads is switched on in Commerce Manager, Meta may display them in your ads automatically. The fix is a Commerce Manager setting.
So a discount meant for one audience can now go looking for another one on its own. If a customer screenshots an offer you never approved, does your support team honor it?

Reach marketing leaders through us
You’re reading this, and so are nearly 20,000 of your peers. Some of them are your next customers.
If you sell to marketing teams, a single placement is €500 and a full week is €2,000.
If you want to place an ad, simply reply to this email or check our media kit.
From our other newsletters today:
AI-Ready Ads: Hammerson made six Christmas films from one shoot Unbound used AI-assisted production to version one film for each of Hammerson's UK destinations.
AI-Ready GTM: Turn your discovery questions into an AI-built calculator lead magnet Lilach Bullock says hers took three hours and got 47 sign-ups in month one.
AI-Ready CMO








