Let me introduce a concept that I think explains what's happening in the job market better than any "AI is taking jobs" headline: the strategy-execution divide.
It's simple. Every role sits somewhere on a spectrum. On one end, you're deciding what to build and why. On the other end, you're executing someone else's decisions. The gap between those two positions is widening fast, and AI is the wedge driving them apart.
Nowhere is this more visible than in marketing.
Bloomberry just published research tracking 180 million job postings from 2023 to 2025, and while the data is messy and imperfect, the pattern is unmistakable. Job postings overall dropped 8% in 2025. Most marketing roles hovered around that benchmark—nothing dramatic. But look closer, and you see the divide opening up.
Writers are down 28%. Copywriters, technical writers, people producing the 500-word blog post someone already outlined. Computer graphic artists—the ones executing layouts in fifteen different sizes—down 33%. But creative directors? Graphic designers who spend their time interpreting client feedback and making strategic calls about visual direction? Basically fine.
And then there's the outlier: influencer marketing specialists jumped 18%. The only marketing role showing real growth is almost entirely judgment work. Which creator actually connects with which audience? What cultural moment should we tap into? How do we build a relationship that feels authentic? AI can't do any of that. But AI can absolutely write your email nurture sequence, generate your product page variations, and produce your social media assets.
Execution work is declining while strategic work is holding steady. And this isn't just about creative roles. Senior leadership positions across all functions declined just 1.7% while individual contributor roles dropped 9%.
Companies want more people deciding what to do, fewer people managing how it gets done, and even fewer people actually executing.
This makes economic sense, even if it feels brutal. The bottleneck used to be production capacity. Can we make this asset? Can we write this copy? Can we design this page? AI has essentially eliminated that bottleneck. Now the constraint is strategic: Should we make this? What exactly should it say? Who is it really for? Those questions still require humans.
If your job—or your team's jobs—are primarily about producing assets, following templates, or implementing decisions someone else made, you're in the danger zone. Not because your work isn't good, but because the market value of pure execution is collapsing.
The people who answer "what should we make and why" are the ones companies are keeping. And the strategy-execution divide isn't just about seniority. A junior marketer who owns campaign strategy is safer than a senior copywriter who executes briefs. A designer who shapes creative direction is safer than an art director who produces final assets.
So ask yourself: when someone describes your role, do they talk about what you decide or what you produce? Because the market is increasingly paying for one and automating the other.
— Torsten & Peter
Today’s sponsor
Want to get the most out of ChatGPT?
ChatGPT is a superpower if you know how to use it correctly.
Discover how HubSpot's guide to AI can elevate both your productivity and creativity to get more things done.
Learn to automate tasks, enhance decision-making, and foster innovation with the power of AI.
Free Workshop Replay: 3 Ways To Level Up Your AI Marketing
The biggest blocker to AI adoption isn't technology. It's people. And the reason your AI pilots don't scale isn't because the tech doesn't work—it's because you're trying to transform everything at once instead of building repeatable systems.
This workshop breaks down how to fix both problems. You'll learn:
strategic prompting that gets you near-perfect first drafts in one shot,
how to identify high-ROI pilots that prove value in weeks, not quarters,
and the AIM Framework for scaling AI adoption across skeptical teams.
Thirty minutes. Three frameworks. Immediate implementation guidance.
This is a replay from our Pro members-only series—Pro members receive more workshops with Q&As, but this free replay provides the foundational content.
» Watch now: 3 Ways to Level Up Your AI Marketing Workshop
» Get full access with Pro: https://aireadycmo.com/upgrade
Our partner newsletter:
Stop letting weekly publishing drain time from you or your team.
LetterOperators delivers a ready-to-send Beehiiv newsletter every week for $499/month — no hiring, no freelancers, no distraction. Just consistent, high-quality publishing done for you.
We build a brand-trained AI workflow paired with human editing — refined through years of multi-LLM editorial work — so you stay focused on strategy instead of content cycles.
Subscribe to AI Operators for weekly insights on using AI to scale newsletters — and see the system CMOs rely on for consistent output without extra headcount.
